VanCleave's Science Fun

Your Guide to Science Projects, Fun Experiments, and Science Research

  • Home
  • ASK JANICE
  • Teacher Guide
  • Homeschool Science For Kids
Home » Positive Constructive Corrections

Positive Constructive Corrections

By Janice VanCleave

Some students are just smarter than others. I am not really talking about high I.Q.s, instead some kids have an usual amount of information stored in their brains. This may sound like a dream student, but rarely is this the case. Often these” brainiacks”  are the kids that thrive on finding fault in what teachers  say.

Solution

A friend gave me the perfect solution to this problem. She confessed that her “Encyclopedia Brain Child ”  kept her on her toes throughout the entire school year.

The child listened for mistakes and was quick to correct her.

Instead of being upset with these interruptions,  she praised him when he caught any little mistake.

The result was that he became the best listener in the class. In fact, the child listened to  every spoken syllable coming out of her mouth.

Instead of the child being a disturbance, she actually relied on him to catch her mistakes.

My guess is that other kids caught on and were also more attentive in hopes that they too would catch the teacher making a mistake.  Since classroom etiquette was part of her instructions, all corrections had to be with a positive  attitude.

I had the honor of visiting this class–Sounds a bit gooshy to say that it was a day that most teachers dream about. As a science presenter, it was a dream group to work with.

How did I respond to being critiqued by 5th graders? I was smart and didn’t talk about things that I don’t know about. My first move was to let the kids know that I am a ” techno newbie.”  There were immediate offers to teach me.

I ask one of the students a question, and he was not able to answer it. So I began to explain. Before I could actually give “the punch line” he started waving his hand and excitedly said, ” I know! I know!”

He didn’t want me to tell him the answer. I was so thrilled.

My friend has given her students much more than facts. She has created a safe environment in which to express themselves. She daily demonstrates that its OK not to know all the answers. She has also taught them how to give constructive corrections. What a wonderful gift!

Share this:

  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Filed Under: General Science

Topic Search

Visitors From All Over the World


Welcome to Janice’s Science Extravaganza!

The spoon hanging from the string vibrates when struck and these vibrations are transmitted through the string and the sound is amplified by the plastic cups. ABOUT ME: Hi, I am Janice VanCleave, author of 50 best-selling science experiment books for children ages 4 through high school. I taught science for 27 years. MORE.....

Copyright © 2025 · Janice Van Cleave · JVC's Science Fair Projects · Log in